Chapter 10 - The Buckeye Lake Boathouse
The midnight drive along Route 33 toward Buckeye Lake was a blur of wet asphalt, towering pine shadows, and sweeping headlights cutting through the dense autumn fog. The rain had started again, drumming a frantic, rhythmic tattoo against the windshield of Alexander’s SUV as we tore through the dark countryside at well over eighty miles per hour.
Neither of us had spoken in twenty minutes. Alexander kept his eyes locked on the dark ribbon of road ahead, his hands gripping the steering wheel with such intensity that his fingers were rigid. I stared out the passenger window, my mind racing through every dark, hidden corner of my family's history.
Uncle Robert. The tragedy twenty-five years ago. The missing photo album. And now, Lucas—cornered, desperate, and unhinged—racing toward an abandoned boathouse to unearth a secret that my father had guarded with his life.
"We're three miles out," Alexander finally broke the silence, his voice tight and controlled. "Leo called ahead. His men checked the property perimeter ten minutes ago. Lucas's car was parked behind the old caretaker's shed. He’s already inside."
"Is Marlene with him?" I asked, my heart pounding against my ribs.
"She's locked in the trunk of Lucas's sedan, tied up, but she's breathing," Alexander replied grimly, glancing at me with a look of fierce reassurance. "Leo’s men have her secured. Right now, our only problem is your brother."
We turned off the main highway onto a narrow, unpaved gravel road that wound its way down toward the dark, churning expanse of Buckeye Lake. Towering oak trees scraped against the sides of the SUV as we killed the headlights, coasting the vehicle into the thick shadow of a rusted tractor shed fifty yards away from the water's edge.
The boathouse loomed ahead like a skeletal monument—a rotting wooden structure perched on weathered concrete pylons over the black water, a single yellow light glowing feebly from its cracked, grime-covered windows.
Alexander reached into his glove box, pulled out a heavy steel-barreled automatic pistol, and checked the magazine with a practiced, silent motion before sliding it into the inside pocket of his coat.
"Stay behind me, Emily," Alexander commanded softly, opening his door.
"I'm not staying in the car, Alexander," I said, opening my door and stepping out into the freezing drizzle. "This is my family. I'm going in with you."
Alexander didn't argue. He gave a sharp nod, and together, we moved silently across the wet gravel toward the rotting wooden dock that led to the boathouse entrance.
The damp smell of rotting wood, stagnant water, and old iron hung heavy in the air. As we reached the heavy sliding door of the boathouse, we could hear Lucas's frantic voice echoing loudly from inside, bouncing off the hollow wooden walls.
"...you think you're so smart, don't you?!" Lucas was screaming inside, sounding unhinged. "You think you can just march in here and take everything? Dad left this here for a reason! He knew you were coming!"
Alexander motioned for me to stay to the left of the door while he crept silently to the right. He raised his hand, counting down with his fingers: Three... Two... One...
With a sudden, violent kick, Alexander smashed the wooden door off its rusted hinges, sending it crashing onto the floorboards inside as he swept his pistol forward, shouting, "Federal Marshals—drop your weapon!"
Except there were no federal marshals.
May you like
And Lucas wasn't pointing a gun at an empty room.
Standing in the center of the rotting boathouse, illuminated by a single dangling overhead bulb, Lucas had a heavy iron crowbar pressed against the neck of a terrified, bound woman—not Aunt Marlene, but someone else entirely. And standing across from him in the shadows, holding the open safety deposit box with a stack of yellowed documents in his hands, was a man I had never seen before in my life—a man whose face turned pale as he looked directly at Alexander and me.
