Chapter 2 - The Trash Can Secret
“Emma,” Alessandro repeated, his voice dangerously soft through the hollow-core door. “Open the door.”
My entire body turned to ice. The plastic trash bag slipped from my fingers, hitting the tile with a soft rustle. How? How had he found me? I had used a false name at the hotel, paid cash for my transportation, and lived in a neighborhood where nobody asked questions. The Vitalis owned Chicago, but a girl from a greasy-spoon diner shouldn't have even been a blip on their radar.
“You have the wrong apartment,” I choked out, pressing my back flat against the shower curtain as if a flimsy piece of vinyl could protect me. “My name isn't—there’s no Emma here.”
A low, humorless chuckle echoed from the hallway.
“Emma,” Alessandro said again, his tone dropping an octave, carrying an absolute, terrifying weight that demanded obedience. “You left your silver pendant on the nightstand in Room 1520. The one with your initials stamped on the back. E.C. Elizabeth Collins. It took my men less than four hours to trace your employment records at the diner and match your handwriting from the applicant log.”
My hand flew to my throat. The silver necklace my mother had given me before she died—I had realized it was missing two days after the gala, but I had convinced myself it must have slipped down a ballroom drain.
“I’m opening the door now, Emma,” he continued smoothly. “We can do this quietly, or my men can take the hinges off. Your choice.”
The doorknob turned.
Panic surged through my veins like liquid fire. I lunged forward, grabbing the bathroom trash can, frantically trying to dig down to the bottom where the pregnancy test packaging lay exposed. If he saw it—if he put together the timeline—my life as I knew it was entirely over.
Before my fingers could claw through the paper, the door pushed open.
Alessandro filled the small bathroom frame. He wore a dark wool overcoat dusted with melting sleet, his broad shoulders practically blocking out the light. His amber eyes swept over the cramped space, taking in the peeling wallpaper, the cracked tile, and finally, me—standing barefoot in my faded diner uniform, trembling like a trapped animal.
His gaze dropped to the floor, tracking the plastic trash bag and my outstretched hand hovering nervously over the open wastebasket.
“What are you hiding?” he asked softly.
“Nothing,” I gasped, backing away until my hips hit the edge of the sink. “Please. Just leave me alone. I didn't ask for any of this. I’m nobody. I’m just a waitress.”
Alessandro didn't answer. He stepped past me, his tall frame making the small bathroom feel suffocatingly narrow. The crisp, clean scent of cedarwood and cold rain washed over me, instantly reviving every memory of that night in the Obsidian Hotel.
He bent down, ignoring the grime on the linoleum, and reached directly into the open wastebasket.
My heart stopped beating.
His large, calloused fingers brushed past the cotton balls, the wrappers, and the crumpled receipts. They closed around a small, rectangular piece of cardboard and plastic.
The box of the early-response pregnancy test.
Alessandro stood up slowly, the box clutched in his hand. The two pink lines were clearly visible on the instruction diagram printed on the cardboard, but it was the small, digital receipt stuck to the back that caught his eye—time-stamped from a pharmacy three blocks away, dated less than an hour ago.
He looked down at the box, then slowly raised his amber eyes to meet mine.
The air in the room vanished. His expression didn't shift into anger, nor did it soften into joy. It hardened into something ancient, possessive, and completely unreadable.
“Whose is this?” he asked, his voice dangerously quiet.
“It’s—it’s a mistake,” I whispered, tears pricking hot behind my eyelids. “It doesn't belong to me.”
Alessandro took a slow step closer, invading my space until I could feel the heat radiating from his chest. He reached out, his long fingers gently catching my chin, forcing me to look up into his fierce, unblinking eyes.
May you like
“I don't make mistakes when it comes to things that belong to me,” he murmured, his thumb brushing my lower lip. “And you, Elizabeth Collins... you belong to me now.”
---
